Maybe the past month has just been a bad extended April Fool's joke. Maybe Oliver Perez is actually Mr. Consistency. Maybe the Mets are actually good hitters in the clutch. Maybe they're actually "the team to beat..."
I wish these things were true. Realistically, after watching Wednesday's series finale against the Florida Marlins, the most glaring things the New York Mets have shown through April are that they are consistently inconsistent, poor hitters in the clutch, and at this point, not even close to being "the team to beat."
Blowing yet another gem of a performance by Johan Santana, the Mets wrapped up a disappointing April with a 4-3 loss to the Marlins, dropping them to fourth in the NL East at 9-12. I'm aware that it's too early to jump ship 21 games into the season, but the season is 1/8 of the way through, and at this rate, the Mets will end up 32 games out of first place.

The shortcomings of the Mets' club have been well documented by the ever-present New York media. Frankly, a lot seems to have been forgotten since 2006, when the Mets had a swagger and cockiness about them that in itself seemed to have opponents beat, even on days when they weren't at their best. There is something off with this team, and I believe it starts at the top, not on the field.
The 2009 Mets have been less than memorable in so many ways, starting with the very building they play in- Citi Field. Yes, the ballpark is beautiful, but there seems to be no sense of tradition, nostalgia, or anything resembling pride within the Met organization. Evidently, nowhere in the blueprints did they include any Met insignia, as the ballpark is practically void of any representation of Mets history. To boot, the first game ever played in the new home of the Mets didn't even involve the Mets. Hell, they were even going to get rid of Doc Gooden's signature on a wall in the outfield before they realized, hey, maybe that's completely asinine. Maybe I'm being picky, but in listening to callers on WFAN, clearly I'm not alone on this issue.

In all these lost nuances of the game, the Mets have forgotten the keys to winning, and in their lackluster start, have provided a constant reminder of the '07-'08 seasons that the fans wish they could forget. Yet, despite all these negatives, there are certainly reasons to still have hope. After all, it is only May. Believe me, as a die-hard Mets fan, the positives are hard to find. But last season it took the Mets until the end of June to wake up, so being only four games back at this juncture is not an insurmountable challenge. Of course, for this to happen, a lot of things must improve.
Johan Santana is the one concrete link in the rotation, but John Maine's 6 inning 0 ER performance against the Marlins on Monday lowered his ERA from 7.47 to 5.40, and was at the very least a step in the right direction. The bullpen, despite a shaky outing here or there, is much improved from last year's disaster.
At the plate, the Mets have been knocked for not hitting in the clutch, and rightfully so. They are 18th in the league with a .252 team batting average with runners in scoring position, and an appalling .179 with the bases loaded. Carlos Delgado is the team home run leader with just 3 dingers. Yes, these things must improve, and drastically so. But there have been bright spots in the lineup, which one would figure, at some point, would have to come together at once and help the Amazins' put together a solid string of games.
Luis Castillo, before being sidelined with back spasms, had bounced back nicely from a down year in 2008, and is batting .370 with an OBP of .433. Omir Santos

(Click for Santos' Grand Slam, 4/27 vs. FLA)
Carlos Beltran (.388) is leading the National League in batting, second in the majors behind Kevin Youkilis (.405), who is simply tearing the cover off of the ball. Ryan Church has responded extremely positively to the addition of Gary Sheffield; rather than being disgruntled, Church is hitting .313 and is tied with David Wright for third on the team with 8 RBI.
As for Wright, despite his massive strikeout total, his career numbers are reason enough to give him the benefit of the doubt. David got off to a slow start in 2007, posting just 6 RBI with a .244 average in a homerless April, but ended the season at .325/30/107.
If Wright is going to be the face of this team, he's going to have to be a leader on the field. 11 strikeouts in 31 at-bats with RISP is unacceptable, but if his career to date is any indication, David Wright will turn things around at the plate, and hopefully the Mets will follow suit. The question is, when?
Well, how about now?
Look, it's a new month. It's time to put April in the rear view and not dwell, because May is huge. The Mets have 16 games against NL East foes. And what better way to usher in the new month with a chance to knock the reigning World Champions down a peg? To kick off May, New York plays 5 of its next 7 games against the Philadelphia Phillies, who boast the National League's worst ERA at 5.63. They avoid Cole Hamels, having to face Chan Ho Park, Jamie Moyer and Joe Blanton, none of whom have an ERA under 5.00, and truthfully, only Moyer (5.09) is within 2 runs of that mark. Additionally, Brad Lidge has come back down to earth; after being just about perfect in 2008, Lidge has blown a save to snap his streak of 49 straight, his ERA is well over 7.00 and opponents are batting .297 against him.
That being said, if nothing else, the Mets bats must come to life. Between the Phils' pitching and the sandbox dimensions of Citizen's Bank Park, any lack of hitting will immensely magnify an already pressing issue for Jerry Manuel's troops. To get good pitching from Pelfrey, Perez and Maine would be a pleasant surprise, yet in all honesty, this point is crucial. For Perez, his start on Saturday may be his last for a while should he turn in another performance resembling the 7-run abomination against the lowly Nationals in his last outing.
If the Mets don't come away from Philly this weekend with at least 2 wins, they are in serious trouble. The last thing this team needs right now is to lose to the team that has cruised past them each of the last 2 Septembers, laughing all the way to their World Series title last season.
This is the Mets' first true test of the season, and it's the one that matters most. This is not just a three game series, this is a psychological battle that will represent just how much or how little heart the 2009 New York Mets really have. This will set the tone for the season one way or another. Either the Phillies win and retain their claim to being "the team to beat," or the Mets send a message to the Phils- and themselves- that not only does this team have a pulse, but it will not go down without a fight. That's what I loved about the 2006 team, and I'm dying to get that feeling back.
Now is the time for David Wright to make this team his team. Now is the time for Oliver Perez to start showing that he does have that upside that the Wilpons are paying $36 million for. Now is the time for the Mets to get their act together and string together one solid at-bat after another, and not let up until K-Rod shuts the door in the 9th. Now is the time to knock the Phillies on their asses and show that there is some fight in this team.